Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Hanover, PA
Miller Hanover Insurance has served South Central Pennsylvania as a one-stop shop for insurance, notary, tag & title, and tax preparation services since 1949. As an independent agency with locations in Hanover and New Oxford, Pennsylvania, we prioritize client needs by comparing rates and coverages across premier insurance providers to ensure optimal protection. Our expertise spans personal and business insurance solutions, including auto, home, life, and specialized commercial policies for contractors, restaurants, and manufacturers. With over 12,000 Erie Insurance policies placed, we combine decades of local knowledge with award-winning service to protect York, Adams, and Carroll County residents. Our commitment extends beyond insurance through trusted tag & title services and IRS-certified tax preparation professionals dedicated to maximizing client savings.
Services
Auto Insurance
Home Insurance
Business Insurance
Life Insurance
Tax Preparation
Notary Services
Tag & Title Processing
Workers Compensation
Commercial Umbrella
Flood Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1949
Highlights and features
- We offer 75+ years of local insurance expertise since 1949
- Our independent agency model compares multiple carriers for best rates
- Specialized business insurance solutions for contractors and manufacturers
- 24/7 policyholder support through Erie Insurance's claims network
- Full-service Hanover office providing insurance, tax, and notary services
What people say
Saved me over $200
Friendly and helpful staff
Highly recommend
Amazing company
Award-winning service
Services
Auto Insurance
Our auto insurance policies protect drivers with liability and comprehensive coverage options. We specialize in standard and specialty vehicle insurance, including collector cars, motorcycles, and commercial fleets. Erie Auto Insurance partners provide award-winning claims service with competitive pricing for Pennsylvania and Maryland drivers.
Home Insurance
Homeowners and renters insurance policies safeguard residential properties against fire, water damage, and liability claims. We offer flood insurance endorsements and specialized coverage for mobile homes, condominiums, and rental properties through Erie Insurance's trusted network.
Business Insurance
Customized business insurance packages protect companies with general liability, workers' compensation, and commercial property policies. Our expertise includes contractors, manufacturers, and hospitality industry coverage across Pennsylvania and Maryland with over 60 years of experience.
Life Insurance
Term and permanent life insurance policies provide family financial protection. Our agents tailor policies to meet individual needs, offering flexible terms and death benefit options through multiple top-rated insurance carriers for Pennsylvania residents.
Tax Preparation
Certified tax professionals prepare federal and state returns with free e-filing and audit assistance. We maximize deductions for Pennsylvania residents and offer year-round support for complex tax situations, including self-employment and investment income reporting.
People
Joan
Insurance Agent
Joan helps clients save over $200 annually on car insurance while providing personalized coverage recommendations. She exemplifies our commitment to cost-effective solutions and exceptional customer service.
Stephanie Keech
Insurance Agent
Stephanie specializes in home and auto insurance bundling, helping clients increase coverage while reducing costs. She provides expert guidance during home purchases and policy transitions.
Jayne Mann
Insurance Agent
Jayne assists with home insurance selection and policy updates, offering personalized service that has saved customers money for five consecutive years through strategic coverage adjustments.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide auto, home, life, and business insurance, including specialized policies for contractors, manufacturers, and commercial fleets.
How do you find competitive insurance rates?
As independent agents, we compare coverage options from multiple carriers to secure the best value for your specific needs.
Do you offer business insurance solutions?
Yes, we create customized commercial packages including liability, workers' compensation, and property insurance for Pennsylvania and Maryland businesses.
What tax services are available?
Our IRS-certified professionals offer complete tax preparation with free e-filing, audit assistance, and year-round tax consultation.
What are your office hours?
Hanover office: Mon & Thu 8:30 AM-7 PM, Tue-Wed & Fri 8:30 AM-5:30 PM. Closed weekends.
How do I file an insurance claim?
Visit our Policy Service Center for 24/7 claims assistance or contact our office during business hours for immediate support.
Videos
Reviews (16)
Elizabeth Nevells
Feb 24, 2017
Report
I've had auto insurance through Miller-Hanover for probably 15 years. In the past five years I feel like I'm constantly calling with requests and have always been made to feel like a valued customer. We've made multiple changes to our policy, adding and taking off vehicles, adding new drivers, new RV, bundled home insurance, etc. Joan Weaver has always helped us to find the policy that was right for our needs at an affordable cost and taken the time to explain them to us. I've also used the tag and title service and have always gotten very friendly and efficient service. I would definitely recommend Miller Hanover!
Sandy Shue
Feb 21, 2017
Report
5 stars! The team at Miller Hanover is awesome. The insurance office and Tag and Title office all have knowledgable and friendly staff. There is a reason I have been a customer there since 08! You can't beat the customer service they provide. I highly recommend them to anyone looking for insurance or tag and title work.
Tasha Yates
Feb 12, 2017
Report
Our agent Jayne Mann is the BEST! She is always easy to work with and is very helpful. She is very knowledgeable regarding our auto and homeowners policies and whenever our policy's are close to renewing she calls if she can get us a better deal. She recently helped us get insurance for an additional vehicle. My husband and I highly recommend Jayne at Miller-Hanover in New Oxford.
Aaron Long
Oct 14, 2016
Report
Miller-Hanover Insurance Agency is the best in the business. When we switched everything over to them (auto, home, etc.), we were not only able to get a better rate but also top-notch customer service. Cristi is awesome to work with. She always makes sure that we have the best rate possible and provides answers to all of our questions in a timely manner. I am so glad that we made the switch to Miller-Hanover Insurance!
Donna Singer
Sep 13, 2016
Report
Joan Weaver is a terrific agent! Not only is she friendly, she's very knowledgeable in the different aspects of insurance and was able to help me get the same or better coverage at a lower cost, for both auto and homeowners. She's also very responsive to calls and emails, and willing to answer any questions I might have. I highly recommend her and Miller-Hanover Insurance.
Amy Sponseller
Aug 21, 2016
Report
We've been with Miller Hanover for over 25 years and have always been very pleased! Our agent Jayne is very knowledgable and helpful. Would definitely recommend them to anyone.our daughter just got her very own auto policy!
Kevin Markle
Aug 15, 2016
Report
After recently having a serious automobile accident. Miller Hanover has been there through every step to ensure an easy going claim process. Everything was handled without hesitation with our well-being in mind! Also, our agent suggested coverage when we started with their service that she would personally have for herself. This made our situation much easier to deal with since we had the proper coverage. Support this local team. They know their stuff! Kevin & Nicole Markle
Carolyn Schmitt
Aug 02, 2016
Report
Joan Weaver of Miller Hanover in the Hanover, PA office has always been most helpful in any questions and/or problems through the many years of service we've had through her! She even evaluates our account from year to year to see if she can offer us any savings. We love her and Miller Hanover! Wouldn't change a thing!
Matthew Charvat
Nov 19, 2015
Report
Miller-Hanover has all of our insurance business! We wouldn't have it any other way. Cristi is great to interact with. When we were living in Maryland, she had the courtesy to call us right before a deadline to save us over $600 on car insurance. She did not have to do that, but went the extra mile for us. We highly recommend Miller-Hanover Insurance. -Matt Charvat
Jeffrey McIntosh
Nov 04, 2015
Report
Jayne Mann at Miller-Hanover is always available to explain policy account changes. She has helped me find the best services for my family. I recommend contacting Jayne Mann if you want to save money on your Auto and/or Home Insurance.
Jacob Stimer
Oct 11, 2015
Report
My agent Jayne made looking for home owner insurance very easy. She was very easy to talk to and answered any questions I had along the way. She found a great, affordable plan to bundle my home insurance with my car insurance. I would definitely recommend this agency and agent to anyone with insurance needs.
Jason Gingrich
Oct 09, 2015
Report
Angela Llewellyn has been a great agent. She's always quick to provide me with documentation or answers to questions that I have. My wife and I have multiple vehicles and multiple policies and Erie's prices are always the best when shopping around. Have had a couple of claims that were always settled quickly and to the expectations that I have. Highly recommend.
Grace Pena
Oct 01, 2015
Report
My agent Jayne Mann is very friendly and helpful with anything from questions to updating your policy! She is always there when you need anything! I highly recommend Jayne to anyone needing insurance! You will not be disappointed! I have been a customer with Miller Hanover Insurance for 5 years and every year they save us money with our auto and home policies.
Alana Leeti
Sep 11, 2015
Report
My entire family has been using Miller Hanover for as long as I can remember. They always make time for their customers and work hard to get the best rates possible. My agent Angela Llewellyn is extremely knowledgeable and helpful!
Todd Albright
Aug 07, 2015
Report
I have been a customer with Miller Hanover Insurance for 30 years, starting out with just auto then house and also motorcycle insurance. Last year I totaled my truck in an accident, Miller not only responded to my situation immediately, but they made everything very easy for me. This includes renting a car to receiving a check to pay off my truck and get another car. Anytime I call them they are always friendly and very helpful! Miller Hanover has been top notch and if you are considering switching.they are a great choice!
William Nelson
Aug 05, 2015
Report
We have been customers of Miller Hanover for several years. We are very happy with our agent Jayne who has helped us with several policy changes over the years as life has thrown changes our way. Great service great rates. Thank you