Business Details
5 Years
experience
Your Trusted Source for Sports & Non-Sports Card Services in Sarasota
Kenmore Collectibles is your trusted destination for sports card and non-sports card services in Sarasota. Founded by Peter Leventhal, a seasoned professional with over three decades of experience in the collectibles industry, our business combines deep expertise with a commitment to transparency and fairness. After operating a successful sports card shop in Boston for many years, I relocated to Sarasota in 2021 and established Kenmore Collectibles within my familys high-end furniture store, Fine Home Consignments. Our primary focus is on buying, consigning, and facilitating PSA grading services, ensuring clients receive accurate valuations and competitive offers based on thorough market analysis.As the only authorized PSA dealer in Sarasota, we provide expert consultation to help collectors navigate the market, maximize their collections value, and make informed decisions. Our transparent approach emphasizes clear communication, detailed pricing information, and personalized strategies tailored to each clients needs. While our physical location serves as a meeting point for transactions, our services extend to online consignment and direct sales, offering flexibility and convenience. With a reputation built on honesty and reliability, we aim to be your trusted partner in the world of sports card collecting.
Services
Card Consignment
PSA Submissions
Card Consultation
Buying Cards
Selling Cards
Details
- Year established: 2021
Highlights and features
- We have 34 years of experience in the sports card industry.
- We are the only authorized PSA dealer in Sarasota.
- Our transparent pricing reflects real-time market trends.
- We offer personalized strategies to maximize your collection's value.
- We provide expert consultation and grading submission services.
Associations and certifications
- Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA)
What people say
Extremely satisfied
Fair and honest
Five star establishment
Services
Card Consignment
We offer 7-day auctions and fixed-price options for consigning sports and non-sports cards. Our fees range from 10% to 20% of the final price, depending on the card's value and auction type. Clients receive transparent pricing and guidance throughout the process.
PSA Submissions
As Sarasotas only authorized PSA dealer, we handle card submissions for professional grading. We share shipping costs and provide expert advice on maximizing value through grading. No additional fees apply if cards are consigned or sold through us.
Card Consultation
Our consultation services include market valuation, grading guidance, and sales strategy development. For $75/hour, clients gain insights into their collections worth and receive personalized recommendations to optimize returns.
Buying Cards
We buy sports and non-sports cards based on market trends and recent sales data. Graded cards receive higher offers. Dedicated buy pages list current pricing for specific cards, ensuring fair and competitive valuations for sellers.
Selling Cards
Cards are sold via our eBay store with a 10% discount available for direct purchases. We provide personalized assistance, detailed product information, and secure transactions to ensure customer satisfaction and competitive pricing.
People
Peter Leventhal
Owner
Peter Leventhal has over 34 years of experience in the sports card industry. He previously owned a successful Boston card shop and now operates Kenmore Collectibles in Sarasota, specializing in transparent transactions and expert consultation.
Questions
What services does Kenmore Collectibles offer?
We provide card consignment, PSA grading submissions, expert consultation, and buying/selling services for sports and non-sports cards.
How does the consignment process work?
Choose between a 7-day auction or fixed-price listing. Fees range from 10% to 20% of the final price, with no additional charges if cards don't sell.
Are you an authorized PSA dealer?
Yes, we are Sarasota’s only authorized PSA dealer, offering grading submission services with shared shipping costs.
How are card values determined?
Values are based on recent eBay sales data, card condition, and market trends. Graded cards receive higher offers.
What are your business hours?
We are open Monday through Saturday from 11:00 AM to 4:00 PM. Appointments are recommended for consultations.
