Business Details
42 Years
experience
Your Trusted Insurance Partner in Three Rivers, MI
Preferred Insurance has been a trusted name in the insurance industry for four decades. Founded by Paul Shingledecker in 1984, our agency began with a vision to provide personalized insurance solutions rooted in Christian values. Over the years, we have expanded to six locations and partnered with over 20 elite insurance carriers while maintaining our family-oriented approach. Our team of licensed agents specializes in personal and commercial insurance, offering tailored solutions to meet individual client needs. With expertise in package policies, competitive pricing, and flexible payment plans, we prioritize client education and transparency.Our mission, inspired by biblical principles, is to alleviate financial burdens through superior coverage and unwavering support during challenging times. As part of Trucordia, we continue to uphold our commitment to exceptional service while leveraging industry-leading resources. Our 17,000 satisfied customers and 25 dedicated professionals attest to our enduring focus on integrity and community. We remain locally operated with a deep understanding of regional insurance requirements, ensuring clients receive both national expertise and personalized care.
Services
Personal Insurance
Commercial Insurance
Life and Health Insurance
Farm Insurance
Medicare Supplement Insurance
Details
- Year established: 1984
Highlights and features
- We offer 40 years of experience in personalized insurance solutions.
- Our team represents over 20 elite insurance carriers for comprehensive options.
- We provide competitive pricing and flexible payment plans tailored to client needs.
- Our agents maintain specialized industry knowledge through continuous education.
- Family-oriented service with a commitment to community values and integrity.
What people say
Saved our family money
Prompt and professional responses
Fantastic agent
Went above and beyond
Highly recommend services
Services
Personal Insurance
Our personal insurance solutions protect your home, vehicles, and family with comprehensive coverage options. We specialize in bundling policies to maximize discounts while ensuring adequate protection. With expertise in life insurance and umbrella liability, we help clients safeguard their assets and future.
Commercial Insurance
We provide tailored commercial insurance packages including liability, property, workers' compensation, and auto coverage. Our specialists understand industry-specific risks and offer customized solutions to protect Michigan businesses. From farms to specialty operations, we ensure comprehensive protection for commercial clients.
Medicare Supplement Insurance
Our Medicare experts guide clients through supplemental insurance options to complement Original Medicare coverage. We offer personalized solutions for prescription drug plans, Medigap policies, and Medicare Advantage plans, helping seniors navigate complex insurance decisions with clarity and confidence.
Farm Insurance
We specialize in comprehensive farm insurance solutions covering property, liability, and crop protection. Our agents understand the unique needs of agricultural operations, from hobby farms to commercial dairy operations, providing tailored coverage to protect rural enterprises and equipment.
Life Insurance
Our life insurance offerings include term and permanent policies designed to protect families and businesses. We help clients determine appropriate coverage amounts and beneficiaries while integrating policies into broader estate and retirement planning strategies for long-term financial security.
People
Paul Shingledecker
Founder
Founded Preferred Insurance in 1984 and led the agency for 40 years before retiring in 2024. His legacy of Christian values continues through the agency's family-oriented approach.
Jennie Miller
Operations Manager
Manages daily operations with 18 years of experience. Ensures efficient processes while maintaining client relationships. Directs local high school musicals and integrates faith into professional leadership.
Kelly Kovach
Sales Manager
21-year insurance veteran specializing in client solutions. Builds lasting relationships while leading sales teams. Active in community service and family-oriented activities with 21 years of industry experience.
Lucas Shingledecker
Producer
Manages daily operations with 17 years of insurance expertise. Specializes in personal and commercial lines while coaching youth sports and maintaining community involvement.
Chandler McBrider
Insurance Specialist
Senior agent specializing in Medicare plans and retirement solutions. Active in community service and church activities while providing personalized insurance guidance to senior clients.
Questions
What insurance products do you offer?
We provide personal insurance (home, auto, life), commercial coverage, farm policies, and Medicare supplement plans through 20+ elite carriers.
Are you affiliated with Trucordia?
Yes, we joined the Trucordia network in 2024 while maintaining local ownership and operations in Three Rivers, Michigan.
Do you specialize in senior insurance?
Yes, we offer Medicare Advantage, Supplement, and Prescription Drug plans with specialists who simplify complex insurance decisions for retirees.
What areas do you serve?
Primarily serving Three Rivers, Michigan and surrounding communities with personalized insurance solutions since 1984.
Can I get farm insurance quotes?
Yes, our specialists provide customized farm insurance coverage for hobby to commercial operations. Contact us for competitive quotes tailored to your agricultural needs.
