Business Details
Specialized Insurance for Purpose-Driven Organizations
Church Mutual Insurance has been dedicated to protecting purpose-driven organizations for over 125 years. Founded in 1897, we specialize in tailored insurance solutions for religious institutions, nonprofits, schools, and human service organizations, addressing their unique risks with expertise and understanding. Our commitment extends beyond insurance through extensive risk management resources, safety tools, and community initiatives like CM CARES, which has donated over $2.4 million to local causes.With a team of around 1,000 employees and operations in all 50 states, we combine deep industry knowledge with personalized service to ensure our clients can focus on their missions with confidence. Our history of innovation includes pioneering online insurance solutions for smaller organizations and developing specialized coverage products to meet evolving challenges.
Services
Property Insurance
Liability Insurance
Workers Compensation
Risk Management Resources
Safety Products
Telemedicine Services
Background Checks
Cybersecurity Tools
Volunteer Safety Programs
Specialized Coverage
Highlights and features
- We specialize in insurance solutions tailored to religious and nonprofit organizations.
- Our risk management resources help prevent and mitigate unique organizational challenges.
- 125+ years of experience serving churches, schools, and community-focused groups.
- Comprehensive coverage options eliminate the need for multiple insurance providers.
- CM CARES foundation supports charitable causes and community initiatives nationwide.
What people say
Professional and prompt
Second to none
Great to work with
Easy to get a hold of
Prompt and trustworthy
Services
Property Insurance
Our Property Insurance safeguards buildings, equipment, and inventory with comprehensive coverage tailored to religious and nonprofit organizations. We address unique risks like seasonal events and volunteer activities while providing resources to prevent losses. This protection allows clients to focus on their missions without worrying about unexpected property damage.
Liability Insurance
Liability Insurance protects against claims from bodily injury, property damage, or misconduct allegations during organizational activities. Our policies cover legal expenses and settlements while offering guidance to minimize exposure. This ensures organizations can operate community programs and events with confidence in their financial protection.
Workers Compensation
Workers Compensation Insurance covers medical expenses and lost wages for employees injured on the job. We provide support for workplace safety compliance and claims management to protect both staff and organizational resources. This service helps maintain a secure environment for the dedicated individuals serving purpose-driven missions.
Risk Management Resources
We offer extensive risk management materials including safety products, educational articles, and specialized programs like cyberattack preparedness and volunteer safety training. These resources help organizations identify vulnerabilities and implement proactive measures to prevent incidents before they occur.
Specialized Coverage
Our Specialized Coverage addresses unique organizational needs through customized policies for camps, schools, and human service groups. This includes protection for transportation, cyber threats, and special events while maintaining flexibility to adapt to evolving challenges faced by purpose-driven entities.
People
Alan S. Ogilvie
President
Alan Ogilvie leads Church Mutual as President, bringing extensive industry experience since joining in 2015. He previously served as Executive Vice President and President of Subsidiaries, focusing on strategic growth and operational excellence across all markets.
Michael Ravn
Former CEO
Michael Ravn served as CEO from 2009-2014, expanding distribution channels to include broker partners. His leadership diversified the policyholder base while maintaining focus on the company's core mission of serving religious institutions.
Rich Poirier
Former CEO
Rich Poirier led Church Mutual as CEO from 2014-2020, establishing the company's first Diversity and Inclusion initiative. He expanded coverage options and strengthened community partnerships through strategic programs and sponsorships.
Questions
What types of organizations do you insure?
We specialize in coverage for religious institutions, nonprofits, schools, human service organizations, and camps nationwide.
How do I file a claim?
File claims through our online portal or contact our Claims Center directly at 800-554-2642 for immediate assistance.
Do you offer risk management resources?
Yes, we provide safety products, educational materials, and specialized programs to help prevent incidents and mitigate risks.
Can I get a personalized quote online?
Yes, use our online quote tool to receive a customized insurance proposal tailored to your organization's specific needs.
Are your policies available nationwide?
We serve organizations in all 50 states through our network of local representatives and brokers.
What community initiatives do you support?
Through CM CARES, we've donated over $2.4M to local causes including United Way and Boys & Girls Clubs.
Videos
