Business Details
50+ Years
experience
Your Trusted Consignment Furniture Store in Oyster Bay
Founded in 1969, Attic Door Furniture has been a trusted name in furniture consignment on Long Island's North Shore for over five decades. Our family-owned business began with a commitment to quality and exceptional customer service, a tradition passed down through three generations. We specialize in curating high-quality, trend-conscious furniture and home decor that reflects both contemporary tastes and timeless treasures. Our team provides free appraisals, personalized consignment services, and daily social media updates to ensure transparency and convenience. With deep roots in Oyster Bay, we combine local expertise with a curated inventory that moves quickly, offering customers unique opportunities to buy and sell premium home furnishings.Our process prioritizes ease for consignors, from same-day appointments to direct family member interactions throughout the sales cycle. We take pride in maintaining a dynamic inventory that satisfies both sellers seeking fair market value and buyers looking for distinctive pieces. Our 50% profit guarantee for consignors and environmentally conscious approach to furniture resale have made us a community staple. Through decades of evolving trends, we've remained dedicated to our core values of reliability, expertise, and personalized service. Today, we continue serving Long Island residents as one of the region's most established consignment destinations, where every visit promises new discoveries.
Services
Furniture Consignment
Home Furnishings Sales
Free Appraisals
In-Home Evaluations
Competitive Pricing Analysis
Details
- Year established: 1969
Highlights and features
- 50+ years of furniture consignment expertise in Oyster Bay
- Family-owned business with direct owner involvement in all transactions
- Free appraisals and same-day appointment availability
- 50% profit guarantee for all consigned items
- Environmentally responsible furniture resale solutions
Services
Furniture Consignment
Our furniture consignment service offers expert pricing and marketing for your home furnishings. We handle all aspects from appraisal to sale, ensuring competitive pricing based on current market trends. With over 50 years of experience, we guarantee 50% profit share while maintaining complete transparency throughout the sales process.
Home Furnishings Sales
Discover curated home furnishings that blend modern trends with timeless pieces. Our inventory changes daily, featuring carefully selected furniture and decor that reflect both contemporary tastes and classic styles. Each item undergoes rigorous evaluation to ensure quality and market appeal before entering our showroom.
Free Appraisals
We provide complimentary, no-obligation appraisals for potential consignment items. Our experts evaluate furniture based on condition, brand recognition, and current market demand. Appointments can be scheduled via phone or email, with in-home evaluations available for larger collections or estate situations.
In-Home Evaluations
Our personalized home evaluation service brings expertise directly to your doorstep. Family members conduct all assessments, offering professional guidance on which items would best suit our market. This service is particularly valuable for downsizing, estate management, or liquidation needs.
Competitive Pricing Analysis
We employ dynamic pricing strategies based on ongoing market analysis. Our approach combines decades of industry experience with current trend monitoring to ensure optimal pricing that balances seller returns with buyer appeal, resulting in typically quick turnover times.
People
Mark Tiberio
Co-Owner
Third-generation furniture consignment expert with lifelong experience in home furnishings valuation. Committed to maintaining family legacy through personalized service and market expertise. Directly oversees inventory selection and pricing strategies.
Brian Tiberio
Co-Owner
Active co-owner with deep knowledge of furniture trends and market dynamics. Focuses on customer relations and digital marketing initiatives. Ensures modern business practices align with traditional family values of integrity and service.
Questions
What types of items do you accept for consignment?
We accept quality furniture, artwork, and decorative home accessories that align with current market trends. Our selection process focuses on items with strong resale potential.
How are prices determined for consigned items?
Pricing considers current market trends, item condition, brand recognition, and comparable sales data. Our family's decades of experience informs all pricing decisions.
What payment options are available for buyers?
We accept major credit cards, cash, and local checks for furniture purchases at our Oyster Bay location.
How long does it typically take for items to sell?
Most items sell within a week due to our curated inventory approach and active marketing through daily social media updates.
Do you offer delivery services?
We provide delivery arrangements for purchased items, with details coordinated directly through our staff during the sales process.
What areas do you serve for in-home evaluations?
We primarily serve Long Island's North Shore, including Oyster Bay and surrounding communities for in-home evaluation services.
