Business Details
Freshly Baked Bagels & Deli Favorites in Cary, NC
At New York Bagel & Deli, we take pride in being a family-owned business rooted in tradition and quality. With over 75 years of combined experience in the family bakery industry, we specialize in crafting fresh, scratch-made bagels, pastries, and deli items using time-honored techniques passed down through generations. Our commitment to excellence is evident in every product, from our famous New York-style cheesecakeonce served at Frank Sinatras engagement partyto our handcrafted danishes and crumb cakes.We offer catering services for events of all sizes, including office parties, tailgates, and breakfast or lunch platters, ensuring every customer experiences the same dedication to flavor and authenticity that has defined our familys legacy. Located in Cary, North Carolina, we aim to bring the rich heritage of New York baking to the Triangle area while embracing innovation, such as upcoming cryptocurrency payment options, to meet modern customer needs.
Services
Bagels
Catering
Pastries
Cheesecake
Subs
Highlights and features
- We have over 75 years of family experience in baking and deli services.
- Our products are made from scratch using fresh, quality ingredients.
- We offer catering for events with customizable platters and subs.
- Our New York-style cheesecake recipe is a time-tested favorite.
- We prioritize customer satisfaction with personalized service.
What people say
Best bagels in the Triangle
Cheesecake is amazing
Fresh ingredients
Friendly staff
Great catering options
Services
Bagels
Handcrafted New York-style bagels made daily from scratch using traditional recipes. Our bagels are known for their chewy texture and rich flavor, appealing to locals and visitors alike. Perfect for breakfast or any time of day.
Catering
Custom catering for events including bagel platters, breakfast/lunch trays, and 2-6 foot subs on New York-style Italian bread. Ideal for office gatherings, tailgates, and parties, ensuring fresh, satisfying options for groups of all sizes.
Pastries
Assorted pastries like danishes, cannolis, and crumb cakes baked fresh daily. Combines classic techniques with family recipes to deliver indulgent treats that highlight our commitment to quality and tradition in every bite.
Cheesecake
Famous New York-style cheesecake recipe passed down through generations. Known for its creamy texture and rich taste, its a standout favorite that connects our customers to our familys culinary heritage and history.
Subs
Handmade subs on New York-style Italian bread with premium meats and fresh toppings. Available in 2-6 foot sizes, these subs offer a hearty, customizable option for catering events or quick meals on the go.
People
Thomas Nurrito
Co-Owner
Thomas Nurrito co-owns New York Bagel & Deli with his wife Josephine. As the youngest of four brothers, he continues the familys 75-year baking legacy, ensuring every product meets their high standards for quality and authenticity.
Josephine Nurrito
Co-Owner
Josephine Nurrito partners with her husband Thomas to run New York Bagel & Deli. Her dedication to the familys baking traditions and customer service ensures the Cary location maintains the same excellence as their other establishments in Sedona and New York.
Questions
What catering options are available?
We offer bagel platters, breakfast/lunch trays, and 2-6 foot subs for events. Contact us for pricing and customization.
Do you offer vegan or gluten-free options?
Current options are limited, but we recommend checking with our staff for the latest updates on dietary accommodations.
Are you open on holidays?
Our regular hours apply unless otherwise posted. Please call ahead for holiday-specific schedules.
Will you accept cryptocurrency payments?
Yes, we plan to introduce crypto payment options soon for added convenience.
What makes your cheesecake special?
Our family recipe, perfected over decades, was once served at Frank Sinatra’s engagement party for its unmatched creaminess and flavor.
Do you deliver orders?
Delivery availability varies; contact us directly to inquire about delivery for your order.
