Business Details
Your Trusted Bakery in Centereach, NY
For over 50 years, Benkerts has been a cornerstone of Long Island's culinary community, dedicated to crafting exceptional baked goods with unwavering commitment to quality. Founded by the Lorch and Janke families, our bakery combines four generations of expertise with a passion for using only the finest ingredients to create products that exceed customer expectations. Our tradition of excellence extends beyond our fresh pastries, rolls, and breads to include custom wedding cakes, extreme cakes, layer cakes, cheesecakes, and coffee cakes that transform special occasions into unforgettable memories.We take pride in treating every customer like family, ensuring that each visit to our Centereach location reflects the same dedication to freshness, quality, and reliable service that has defined our business since 1974. Our skilled bakers and decorators work tirelessly to deliver exceptional value, maintaining our reputation as the premier bakery for both everyday indulgences and life's most significant celebrations.
Services
Fresh Pastries
Custom Cakes
Wedding Cakes
Layer Cakes
Cheesecakes
Coffee Cakes
Highlights and features
- Four generations of baking expertise since 1974
- Only premium ingredients used in all products
- Skilled bakers and decorators for custom creations
- Daily fresh-baked goods available seven days a week
- Specialty in wedding and occasion cakes with unique designs
What people say
Exceptional quality
Friendly service
Beautiful cake designs
Fresh daily offerings
Family tradition
Services
Fresh Pastries
Our bakery offers a wide selection of fresh-baked pastries daily, including croissants, danishes, and specialty items made with premium ingredients. Perfect for breakfast or any time treat, our pastries feature flaky crusts and quality fillings. Each creation combines traditional techniques with modern flavors to satisfy every palate.
Custom Cakes
Benkerts specializes in custom-designed cakes for any occasion, from birthdays to corporate events. Our skilled decorators transform your vision into edible art using advanced techniques and high-quality materials. Whether you prefer classic styles or modern designs, our team ensures your cake becomes the centerpiece of your celebration.
Wedding Cakes
We create stunning wedding cakes that reflect each couple's unique style and theme. Our bakers use premium ingredients to craft multi-tiered masterpieces with intricate details. From traditional buttercream designs to contemporary fondant finishes, we ensure your wedding cake combines visual beauty with exceptional taste for your special day.
Layer Cakes
Our layer cakes feature multiple tiers of moist cake filled with rich frostings and creative combinations. Available in various flavors and sizes, these cakes suit any celebration. Our bakers use time-tested recipes and professional techniques to ensure perfect texture and flavor in every slice, making our layer cakes a customer favorite.
Cheesecakes
Benkerts cheesecakes combine creamy textures with perfect crusts for a classic dessert experience. We offer traditional New York style and specialty flavors with premium dairy products. Each cheesecake is baked fresh daily using our signature recipes developed over decades, ensuring consistent quality and rich flavor that keeps customers returning.
Questions
What are your bakery hours?
We're open Monday-Friday 7am-6pm and Saturday-Sunday 6am-6pm.
Do you offer custom cake designs?
Yes, our Cake Wizards create custom designs for weddings, birthdays, and special events.
Are your baked goods made fresh daily?
All our products are baked fresh daily using premium ingredients.
Can I place special orders?
Yes, we accept special orders for cakes and baked goods with advance notice.
What payment methods do you accept?
We accept major credit cards, debit cards, and cash payments.
Do you deliver your baked goods?
Delivery options are available for large orders within Long Island.
