Find 10 Recommended Local Insurance Agencies in Indiana

Read profiles and customer feedback for 10 recommended insurance agencies serving Indiana, including Indianapolis, Fort Wayne and Gary. Check the coverage types they handle and contact appropriate agencies to discuss your insurance requirements and request quotes.
We have over 35 years of experience in commercial insurance and risk management.
Haywood & Fleming Associates offers expert insurance and risk management solutions for commercial clients in Gary, IN. Established in 1984, we provide tailored services to meet your business needs.
Risk Assessment Employee Benefits Risk Management
Not rated yet
The Insurance Exchange
40 Years
Not rated yet
We offer coverage through top-rated insurance carriers nationwide
Get personalized insurance solutions from The Insurance Exchange, South Holland's trusted independent agency since 1986. We offer auto, home, life, and business insurance with competitive rates.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Not rated yet
General Insurance Services
50+ Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
We offer over 80 years of experience in Northern Indiana insurance markets
Protect what matters most with personalized insurance solutions from General Insurance Services. Serving Northern Indiana since 1930, we offer home, auto, business, and employee benefits insurance with exceptional service.
Home Insurance Auto Insurance Business Insurance
We have over 40 years of experience in insurance and tax services
Specializing in beauty industry insurance and tax services since 1983. Licensed nationwide provider of health, life, and business insurance solutions with personalized client support.
Health Insurance Life Insurance Auto Insurance
We have 30+ years of experience serving Indiana businesses since 1994
Source One Insurance offers tailored commercial, personal, and cyber insurance solutions in Fort Wayne, IN. With 30+ years of experience, we provide personalized service and industry-specific coverage for businesses and individuals.
Commercial Insurance Personal Insurance Employee Benefits
Not rated yet
Colligan
50+ Years
Not rated yet
We have over 90 years of experience serving Fort Wayne communities
Colligan offers personalized insurance solutions for individuals and businesses in Fort Wayne, IN, prioritizing client needs through independent, community-focused service since 1929.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Not rated yet
Classic Insurance Agency
34 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Specializing in classic car insurance since 1992 with 25+ years of industry expertise
Trusted classic car insurance provider offering tailored policies for collector vehicles. Agreed value coverage, tiered mileage plans, and nationwide roadside assistance since 1992.
Antique Car Insurance Classic Truck Insurance Exotic Car Coverage
Not rated yet
SECURA Insurance
Emergency
Not rated yet
We offer 125 years of experience protecting businesses and farms.
SECURA Insurance offers tailored property-casualty insurance solutions for businesses, farms, and nonprofits since 1900. Based in Neenah, WI, we provide reliable coverage and exceptional service through independent agents across 13 states.
Business Insurance Farm Insurance Cyber Security
Not rated yet
CNA
Not rated yet
We offer 125+ years of expertise in commercial insurance solutions.
CNA offers tailored business insurance solutions for industries worldwide. With over 125 years of experience, we provide risk management and insurance services to protect your business.
Commercial Auto Insurance Cyber Insurance Workers' Compensation