Find 7 Recommended Local Insurance Agencies in Ohio

Read profiles and customer feedback for 7 recommended insurance agencies serving Ohio, including Dayton and Toledo. Check the coverage types they handle and contact appropriate agencies to discuss your insurance requirements and request quotes.
We offer 24/7 online policy management and customer service access.
Get personalized insurance solutions from JL Tillman Insurance Agency in Springfield, IL. We offer auto, home, health, and commercial insurance with 24/7 policy access.
Automobile Insurance Homeowners Insurance Renters Insurance
We provide credit union-specific insurance programs developed over 30+ years of industry experience
Freimark & Associates offers specialized insurance programs for credit unions including credit life insurance, collateral protection, and GAP coverage across Ohio, Arkansas, and Louisiana.
Credit Life Insurance Credit Disability Insurance Collateral Protection Insurance
Not rated yet
Gem City Insurance
50+ Years
Not rated yet
We are a locally-owned agency with deep understanding of Ohio's unique risks
Gem City Insurance offers personalized business and personal insurance solutions in Springboro, OH, with over 76 years of experience and a commitment to client satisfaction.
Contractor Insurance Garage Repair Shop Insurance Real Estate Investor Insurance
Experienced staff with decades of industry knowledge
Wagner Insurance offers personalized auto, home, life, and business insurance solutions in Dayton, OH and surrounding areas. Get a free quote today from our independent, locally owned agency.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Life Insurance
Insure My Rig
50+ Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
Insure My Rig
50+ Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
3rd generation family-owned agency with 80+ years of trucking insurance expertise
Trusted commercial truck insurance provider since 1934. Specializing in owner-operator and fleet coverage with competitive rates, 24/7 support, and 80+ years of industry expertise.
Primary Liability Physical Damage Non-Trucking Liability