Find 18 Recommended Local Insurance Agencies in Illinois

Read profiles and customer feedback for 18 recommended insurance agencies serving Illinois, including Chicago, Peoria and Springfield. Check the coverage types they handle and contact appropriate agencies to discuss your insurance requirements and request quotes.
We offer over 150 years of insurance expertise and personalized service.
Dimond Bros Insurance offers tailored insurance solutions for individuals, businesses, and farms. With 150+ years of experience, we provide personalized coverage across Illinois, Indiana, Wisconsin, and beyond.
Business Insurance Personal Insurance Life & Health Insurance
We represent over 30 insurance carriers for comprehensive coverage options
Prairie State Insurance Agency provides tailored personal and commercial insurance solutions across Illinois, Missouri, Indiana, Wisconsin, Idaho, and Washington. Partnering with 30+ carriers, we offer auto, home, business, health, and life insurance with
Auto Insurance Business Insurance Home Insurance
We offer 70+ years of family-owned insurance expertise in southern Illinois.
Foppe Insurance Agency offers personalized auto, home, business, and life insurance solutions in Breese and Mascoutah, IL, combining 70+ years of expertise with independent carrier representation since 1957.
Auto Insurance Business Insurance Home Insurance
Not rated yet
American Central Insurance
39 Years
Emergency
Not rated yet
30+ years of local insurance expertise since 1987
Comprehensive insurance solutions for Illinois businesses and individuals from experienced independent agents. Serving Springfield and surrounding areas since 1987.
Employee Benefits Commercial Insurance Personal Insurance
Not rated yet
Nixon Insurance
47 Years
Not rated yet
We offer 40+ years of local insurance expertise since 1979
Nixon Insurance offers personalized commercial and personal insurance solutions in Central Illinois. With 40+ years of experience since 1979, we provide tailored coverage for businesses, families, and individuals.
Commercial Insurance Personal Insurance Surety Bonds
Not rated yet
Illinois Mutual
50+ Years
Not rated yet
We offer over 115 years of experience in life and disability insurance.
Illinois Mutual offers life insurance, disability income insurance, and worksite solutions across 47 states. Founded in 1909, we provide personalized coverage with exceptional service and an A- AM Best rating.
Life Insurance Disability Income Insurance Worksite Insurance
Not rated yet
Hediger & Meyers
50+ Years
Not rated yet
We have over 30 years of insurance experience with certified professionals
Hediger & Meyers offers personalized personal, commercial, and employee benefits insurance solutions in Peoria, IL, with over a century of experience in providing reliable coverage and exceptional service.
Personal Insurance Commercial Insurance Employee Benefits
We are independent insurance advisors with multi-state licensing
Get Insured, Inc offers personalized auto, home, and business insurance solutions in Romeoville, IL. As an independent agency, we provide coverage options tailored to your needs across Illinois, Indiana, and Wisconsin.
Auto Insurance Home Insurance Business Insurance
Not rated yet
Risser
40 Years
Not rated yet
We have over 35 years of experience in workers' compensation brokerage
Specialized workers' compensation solutions for independent agents since 1986. Serving Illinois, Iowa, Missouri, and Indiana with reliable carrier partnerships and expert risk placement.
Workers' Compensation Brokerage Hard-to-Place Risk Solutions Experience Mod Analysis