Find 2 Recommended Local Insurance Agencies in Islip, NY

First Choice Insurance is a Long Island-based independent insurance provider offering tailored homeowners, auto, commercial, and flood insurance solutions. We prioritize personalized service, leveraging decades of industry experience to deliver competitive rates and comprehensive coverage. Our client-centric approach ensures policies evolve with changing needs while maintaining transparency and affordability.

Lighthouse Insurance is a New York-based independent insurance brokerage offering personal and commercial insurance products. Established in 1983, we provide competitive quotes from 25+ national and regional carriers through a proprietary platform, emphasizing accurate pricing, real-time comparisons, and comprehensive coverage options for auto, home, flood, and business insurance.